Bright Data wins lawsuit against Elon Musk’s X for data scraping violation

A federal judge in California recently dismissed a lawsuit filed by Elon Musk’s X against Israel’s Bright Data, in a case that revolved around the scraping of public online data and its appropriate use. X, formerly known as Twitter, alleged that Bright Data was scraping data from X and selling it by using technical measures to evade X Corp.’s anti-scraping technology. The lawsuit also claimed that Bright Data was violating X’s terms of service and copyright.

Data scraping involves automated programs that search publicly accessible websites to collect data, which can be used for various purposes such as training artificial intelligence models and targeting online ads. In the United States, data scraping is generally legal when it involves publicly accessible data, as highlighted in a 2022 ruling following a legal battle involving LinkedIn.

X had previously sought over $1 million in damages from unknown defendants for unlawfully scraping data associated with Texas residents. However, Judge William Alsup dismissed the complaint, stating that X Corp. wanted it both ways by seeking to protect its safe harbors while also exercising a copyright owner’s right to exclude and extract fees from those copying X users’ content.

The judge also expressed concerns about social networks having complete control over the collection and use of public web data, warning that it could lead to the creation of information monopolies that would not serve the public interest. He noted that X was not seeking to protect its users’ privacy but rather looking to profit from the extraction and copying of users’ content.

In a statement, Bright Data emphasized that public information online belongs to everyone, and any attempt to deny public access will fail. The company stated that the implications of the case are unprecedented and will impact businesses, research, AI, and beyond. Bright Data clarified that it only scrapes publicly available data visible to anyone without a login and that X had made the information scraped by Bright Data available to the public at the time of the lawsuit.

This case highlights the complexities and legal issues surrounding data scraping and the importance of balancing the rights of data owners with the public’s access to information. It also underscores the challenges faced by companies like Bright Data in navigating legal disputes with tech giants like X. As data continues to play a crucial role in innovation and technology, it is essential for regulations and laws to evolve to address these emerging issues effectively.

Back To Top